That's why "you own your site" on a sales call tells you almost nothing. Own which part? This guide goes through all nine, shows you how to check your contract in about ten minutes, and explains how to leave without losing your place on Google.
One note before we start. This is general information about websites from someone who builds them. It isn't legal advice, and you're the lawyer at this table. Read your own agreement.
Who owns a law firm website? The nine pieces
| Piece | What it is | Who should hold it | How to check in two minutes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domain name | Your address (yourfirm.com) | The firm, as registrant, in the firm's own registrar account | Log in to the registrar. If you can't, you don't control it |
| Hosting account | The server the site runs on | The firm, or a host that will hand over a full copy on request | Ask whose name and card are on the hosting account |
| Software | The system that runs the site | Open software any developer can host, or code you're given | Ask: "Can this exact site run on another host?" |
| Design | The layout, look and code | The firm, by written assignment | Find the ownership clause. Look for "assign" |
| Written content | Bios, practice area pages, posts | The firm, by written assignment | Same clause. Check it covers the vendor's writing too |
| Photos and video | Headshots, office photos, stock | The firm for its own photos. Stock is licensed, not owned | Ask which images are stock and whose license it is |
| Google Business Profile | Your listing on Google Search and Maps | The firm as primary owner. The vendor as manager | Open the profile and see who's listed as primary owner |
| Analytics and Search Console | Your traffic and search history | The firm as administrator and owner | Check your role in each account |
| Phone numbers | Call tracking numbers on the site and ads | The firm, or a written right to take the numbers with you | Ask who the number belongs to and if it can be moved to you |
The rest of this page is the detail behind each row.
The domain name
The domain is the piece that hurts most to lose, because everything else points at it: your email, your Google listing, every link anyone ever made to you.
ICANN, the body that oversees domain names, says the registrant (it also uses the term "Registered Name Holder") is "the person or entity that holds the rights to a domain name." So the question is simple. Who is listed as the registrant: your firm, or the company that set it up?
ICANN's own FAQ covers the common problem. If you hired a third party such as a developer, "they may have registered the domain name using their own contact details," and you may need to show proof of payment to your registrar to prove you're the rightful holder. That's a fixable situation. It's much easier to fix while everyone still likes each other.
It happens inside firms too. In 2016 a California firm sued a former partner, alleging she had registered the firm's domain names and kept control of them after she left. The lawyers who wrote it up for the National Law Review drew the obvious lesson: "Best practices dictate that all domain names be registered to the company or organization."
The hosting account
Hosting is a monthly utility, about $20 a month for a normal small firm site. The account matters less than what sits on it, as long as you can get a complete copy of the site whenever you ask. If the vendor hosts it, get that in writing.
The software the site runs on
This is where most "you own it" promises fall apart.
Some sites run on open software. WordPress, for example, is released under an open license (GPL version 2 or later), so any developer can host it anywhere. Other sites run on a system the vendor built and keeps for itself. A site on a private system can't run anywhere else. You can own every word on it and still be unable to move it.
One large legal website provider's published terms show how this is usually written. The work created for you is assigned to you "subject to your fulfillment of all payment obligations." Then come the exceptions. The provider keeps "all rights" to the "technology, inventions, algorithms, processes, data, software, architecture, source files, source code, and other underlying elements used in the creation or hosting" of the work, and gives you a license to use it. That's a fair, clearly written contract. It just means that what leaves with you is content, not a working website.
The design and the written content
You'd think paying for something makes it yours. With creative work, it doesn't happen on its own, and you know this better than we do.
Under the Copyright Act, copyright "vests initially in the author" (17 U.S.C. 201(a)). A work by an outside contractor counts as a work made for hire only if it falls into one of nine listed categories and both sides sign a written agreement saying so (U.S. Copyright Office, Circular 30). And a transfer of copyright ownership isn't valid without a signed writing (17 U.S.C. 204(a)).
So for the design and for anything the vendor wrote, look for a sentence that assigns it to the firm, and check when. Some contracts assign on launch. Some assign only after every payment in the term is made. One legal marketing company's own FAQ puts it this way: "you own your website after the length of your contract" is complete.
Photos and video
Photos you paid a photographer for are between you and the photographer. Stock images are licensed, never owned, and the license often belongs to the vendor. The provider's terms quoted above exclude "stock imagery" from what's assigned to you. If you leave, you may need new pictures.
Your Google Business Profile
This is your listing on Google Search and Maps: the name, the reviews, the phone number, the hours. Google is on your side here, in writing. Its policies for third parties who manage profiles say that "all end customers must retain ownership or co-ownership of their Business Profile at all times," and that when a client asks to end the relationship, the third party has 7 business days to let them take the profile back.
The roles matter. Owners can add and remove people. Managers can do almost everything else but can't remove you. The right setup is the firm as primary owner and the vendor as manager.
Analytics and Search Console
These accounts hold your history. In Google Analytics, only someone with the Administrator role can add or remove users. In Google Search Console, a verified owner proves ownership with a token placed on the site, and owners can add and remove everyone else. If the vendor created both under its own login and you're a viewer, the history stays with them when you go.
The phone numbers
Many marketing programs put a call tracking number on your site and ads so calls can be counted. Ask who that number belongs to. The legal provider's terms quoted above exclude "call tracking telephone numbers" from what's assigned to the firm. If a tracking number has been on your Google profile and your site for three years, clients have saved it. Find out, before you sign, whether you can take it with you.
What rental-style law firm website contracts usually say
Most monthly contracts say plainly what you're getting. These are the terms to look for, described by type.
- A minimum term. One legal marketing company's own FAQ says it typically requires a 12-month contract for its marketing technology.
- Ownership tied to payment or to the end of the term. See the two examples above.
- A license, not a transfer, for the software. You get to use the system while you pay.
- Content yes, website no. An independent legal software review site lists "Lawyer doesn't own website" as a con of one large legal platform and says that firms leaving it keep the rights to their content but have to set up a new website.
- Third-party pieces excluded. Stock photos, tracking numbers and chat tools.
- Your inquiries stored on their system. The same provider's terms say chat transcripts and call inquiries "will be stored by us." Worth a thought, since a 2010 ABA ethics opinion (Formal Opinion 10-457) says a website that invites people to submit information can create duties to them as prospective clients.
How to check your own law firm website contract in ten minutes
Open the agreement and the order form. Search for these words: own, assign, license, term, renew, terminate, domain. Then answer these questions. Send the ones you can't answer to your vendor, in writing.
- Is the domain registered to the firm, and do we have the registrar login?
- Who owns the design and the code: us, or you? From what date?
- Who owns the written content, including the pages you wrote for us?
- If we stop paying, can another developer take this exact site and host it somewhere else next week?
- What system does the site run on? Is it open software, or yours?
- What exactly do we receive when we leave: files, a database, a content export, or nothing?
- What's the minimum term? Does it renew automatically, and how much notice do you need?
- Does anything cost money on the way out: a transfer fee, an export fee, the rest of the term?
- Is the firm the primary owner of our Google Business Profile?
- Are we administrators on our own analytics and Search Console?
- Whose phone numbers are on our site and our Google profile, and can they be moved to us?
- Where do form submissions and chat transcripts go, who can see them, and how long are they kept?
Question 4 is the test. If the answer is yes, you own a website. If the answer is "we'll export your content," you're renting one.
What "you own it" should mean in writing
If you're about to sign with anyone, us included, these are the sentences to look for. Plain versions are fine.
- The domain is registered in the firm's name, in the firm's account.
- The hosting account is in the firm's name, or the firm gets a complete, working copy of the site on request.
- The design, code and written content are assigned to the firm, and the agreement says on what date.
- The site runs on software any developer can host. No private system is needed to keep it online.
- The firm is primary owner of its Google Business Profile and administrator of its analytics.
- Any phone number shown to the public belongs to the firm or can be moved to it.
- No fee is owed to keep the site online after it's paid for, apart from hosting and the domain.
That last line needs one honest footnote. An owned site still has running costs. Hosting is about $20 a month and a domain is about $11 to $25 a year, both paid to the host and the registrar, not to the builder.
How to leave a law firm website company without losing your site or your rankings
Do it in this order. Don't send the cancellation email first.
- Read the term and the notice period. Know your end date and what leaving costs before anyone knows you're going.
- Secure the domain. Get the registrar login, or ask for a transfer. ICANN's rules say your registrar must give you the transfer code (the "AuthInfo" code) within five calendar days of your request. Plan around the locks: a transfer can be refused within 60 days of the first registration or of a previous transfer, and changing the registrant's name or email can start a 60-day lock too.
- Take ownership of your Google Business Profile. If the vendor won't hand it over, Google has a request process. The current owner gets 3 days to respond. New owners then wait 7 days before they can remove other people, so start early.
- Get administrator access to analytics and Search Console. In Search Console, removing an old owner for good means removing their verification token from the site.
- Export everything you can. Every page's text, every image you own, blog posts, reviews you've collected, form submissions, and a list of every page address on the site.
- Sort out the phone numbers. If a tracking number is on your Google profile or in directories, ask to keep it. If you can't, put your real number back everywhere before you leave.
- Build the new site before the old one goes dark. Then point each old page address to its new one. Google's guidance for moving a site is to map old addresses to new ones, use permanent redirects, and keep them "for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year."
- Then cancel, in writing, the way the contract says to.
If the domain itself is staying with the old vendor, the redirects depend on their cooperation. That's the whole reason step 2 comes second.
When renting a law firm website is fine
Renting isn't wrong. It's a trade, and sometimes it's the right one.
- You've just opened and need something live this month for very little money.
- You're buying marketing, not a website, and the site is just part of the package.
- You know it's a rental, the monthly fee is low, and you'd be fine starting over if you left.
The trouble is only when you think you're buying and you're actually renting. Our guide to law firm website cost does that four-year math with real prices.